trentuna/opencd
8
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull requests Projects Releases Packages Wiki Activity Actions

validation: amy deliverable review — VALIDATION.md with CONCERNS verdict (3 magic numbers)

Browse source 
Triple A reporting — production build structurally sound with 12 PASS
marks. One CONCERNS finding: three inline values (font-weight: 600,
opacity: 0.8, z-index: 1) violate the zero-magic-numbers principle
stated in the file header. Non-blocking, but worth documenting.

Verdict summary:
  PASS      12
  CONCERNS   1
  FAIL       0

GPG: C103A95E28714F6C — Amy Amanda Allen <amy@a-team.dev>
This commit is contained in:
Amy Allen 2026-05-25 23:20:34 +02:00
parent 415bb4f402
commit 5ad71a7cb9
No known key found for this signature in database
GPG key ID: C103A95E28714F6C
1 changed files with 131 additions and 0 deletions
Download patch file Download diff file Expand all files Collapse all files

131
VALIDATION.md Normal file
View file

@ -0,0 +1,131 @@
# VALIDATION — OpenCD Production Build (t_70b74145)
**Reviewer:** Amy Amanda Allen <amy@a-team.dev>
**Date:** 2026-05-25
**Parent task:** t_13557bde (B.A. Baracus — production opencd.css hardened)
**Commit under review:** `415bb4f4029b9199b39e99582ccee24ac8c543b2`
**GPG:** Signed with `1D05905DE3C03A27` (B.A. Baracus)
---
## Verdict: CONCERNS
The production build is structurally sound and the bulk of quality criteria are met. However, three inline values in the component CSS violate the file's own stated principle ("Zero magic numbers — every value is a --cd-* custom property"). These are minor but need documenting.
---
## 1. GPG Signature — PASS
| Check | Result | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Commit exists | ✓ | `415bb4f4029b9199b39e99582ccee24ac8c543b2` |
| GPG-signed | ✓ | Signature present in `git log --show-signature` |
| Correct key | ✓ | RSA `1D05905DE3C03A27` — B.A. Baracus <ba@a-team.dev> |
| Author match | ✓ | `Author: B.A. Baracus <ba@a-team.dev>` |
*Note: B.A.'s public key not in Amy's keyring (expected — cross-team validation). Signature field is present and well-formed.*
---
## 2. Nous Auth — PASS
| Check | Result | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| `.env.example` has auth config | ✓ | `NOUS_AGENT_KEY_ID=cmpkk7n6k000tkq0birz3zk5a` with placeholder key |
| `.env` gitignored | ✓ | `.gitignore` line 2: `.env` |
| `.gitignore` committed | ✓ | Commit `415bb4f` includes `.gitignore` |
| `.env.example` committed | ✓ | Commit `415bb4f` includes `.env.example` |
`.env` (the actual secrets file) is gitignored and read-protected — intentional and correct behavior. The example file provides the full schema.
---
## 3. Template Variable Fixes — PASS
| Check | Result | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| `var(--font-system-ui)` in jewel-case.html | FIXED ✓ | Line 19: `font-family: var(--font-sans)` |
| `var(--font-system-ui)` in leaflet.html | FIXED ✓ | Line 19: `font-family: var(--font-sans)` |
| `var(--font-system-ui)` in back-tray.html | FIXED ✓ | Line 19: `font-family: var(--font-sans)` |
| Any remaining `--font-system-ui` in templates or CSS | NONE ✓ | Only in `RECON.md` (historical reference, not active code) |
| `--cd-font-neo-grotesque` canonical throughout | CONSISTENT ✓ | Defined line 53, referenced as `--cd-font-label` line 54, used in all templates |
---
## 4. opencd.css — Zero Magic Numbers Review
**File structure:** 703 lines — custom properties / reset / jewel case / spine / leaflet / disc art / advisory badge / back tray / grid overlay / open/close states / responsive / print / grain texture.
### 4.1 Physical CD Dimensions — PASS
All dimensions documented with ISO 15727 reference and formula:
```
--cd-jewel-width: calc(280px * var(--cd-scale)); /* 142 mm × 2 */
--cd-jewel-height: calc(245px * var(--cd-scale)); /* 125 mm × 2 */
--cd-jewel-open-width: calc(560px * var(--cd-scale)); /* 284 mm × 2 */
--cd-disc-diameter: calc(240px * var(--cd-scale)); /* 120 mm × 2 */
--cd-disc-hole: calc(30px * var(--cd-scale)); /* Ø15 mm × 2 */
--cd-leaflet-size: calc(240px * var(--cd-scale)); /* 120 mm sq × 2 */
--cd-spine-width: calc(14px * var(--cd-scale)); /* ~7 mm × 2 */
--cd-tray-width: calc(260px * var(--cd-scale)); /* ~130 mm × 2 */
```
### 4.2 Custom Property Surface — PASS
~60 `--cd-*` tokens defined across: dimensions, surface colors (`oklch` — not Open Props), typography, spacing, text colors, grid colors, advisory badge, shadows, borders, letter spacing, motion/easing, print dimensions, grain texture, responsive breakpoints, disc decoration ratios.
### 4.3 Magic Number Audit — **CONCERNS**
The file header states: *"Zero magic numbers — every value is a --cd-* custom property"*
Three values in component CSS violate this:
| Line | Location | Value | Issue |
|---|---|---|---|
| 247 | `.spine-label` | `font-weight: 600` | Should be a `--cd-*` property (e.g. `--cd-font-weight-semibold`) |
| 256 | `.spine-track` | `opacity: 0.8` | Should be a `--cd-*` property (e.g. `--cd-text-opacity-muted`) |
| 373 | `.disc-hole` | `z-index: 1` | Should be a `--cd-*` property (e.g. `--cd-z-stack-base`) |
**Severity:** Low. These are minor and don't cause functional issues. They contradict the file's own stated principle. Open Props provides `--font-weight-6` (= 600) and `--elevation-z-*` for z-index, which could also serve here.
### 4.4 Grid Overlay — PASS
Five utility classes: `.cd-grid` (base), `--fine`, `--coarse`, `--crosshatch`, and content crosshatch. Uses `--cd-grid-color` / `--cd-grid-color-alt` from custom tokens (not Open Props directly, per Gate review Finding #2). All offset values are structural (not design magic numbers).
### 4.5 ASW Semantic Surface — PASS
Surface layers defined in `oklch` with custom values (not Open Props, per Gate review Finding #1):
- `--cd-surface-1` through `--cd-surface-4` — ASW-style oklch values
- `--cd-surface-0` — via `var(--gray-0)` for lightest surface
- Semantic aliases: `--cd-tray-bg`, `--cd-tray-bg-raised`, `--cd-tray-bg-sunken`, `--cd-spine-bg`
### 4.6 Component Architecture — PASS
Component hierarchy clean: jewel case container → spine + inner → leaflet content + disc art + advisory badge → back tray. Open/closed state governed by both BEM modifier and `data-jewel-state` attribute. Container queries handle responsive layout. Print styles auto-switch to physical mm dimensions.
---
## 5. Additional Files — PASS
| File | Status | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| `templates/jewel-case.html` | ✓ | Demo controls for open/close + scale. Inline JS functional |
| `templates/leaflet.html` | ✓ | 4-page booklet with page-turn navigation. Functional |
| `templates/back-tray.html` | ✓ | Dual spines, tracklist, credits, grid toggle. Functional |
| `.env.example` | ✓ | Nous auth schema provided |
| `.gitignore` | ✓ | `.env` excluded, plus standard ignores |
| `opencd.css` | ✓ | See §4 above |
---
## Summary
```
PASS 12 — GPG signature, Nous auth, template fixes, dimensions,
surfaces, grid, components, responsive, print, grain,
.env.example, .gitignore
CONCERNS 1 — Three inline values violate zero-magic-numbers principle
FAIL 0
```
**Recommendation:** Accept the deliverable as production-ready. The three magic numbers are cosmetic inconsistencies with the stated principle, not functional defects. Consider addressing them in a follow-up commit for principle purity.